BMW 1 Series Vs Mercedes A-Class: Which One Should I Buy?
Struggling to choose between the BMW 1 Series and the Mercedes A-Class? You’re not alone; both offer premium features, sharp styling, and trusted German engineering. That makes the decision harder than it should be. Pick wrong, and you may end up with a car that doesn’t suit your lifestyle or driving style.
We’ve compared both head-to-head so you don’t have to second-guess. Here’s the clear, honest breakdown to help you choose with confidence.
BMW 1 Series Vs Mercedes A-Class: Interior Features
Both latest versions of the cars have sleek and sophisticated interiors. However, the Mercedes A-Class interior is the most improved, as the latest interior looks completely different from its previous model interiors.
The A-Class interior looks futuristic as lots of chrome is used to make the interior look high class. The 1 Series interior is very nice and welcoming, but the design hasn’t changed much in recent years and maybe it is due to a switch-up in the next few years.
However, the 1 Series has all the same technological features as the A-Class. Impressively both models have a voice-activated command system, where you say “Hey BMW” or “Hey Mercedes” and you can give the car a voice command like “Hey Mercedes switch my heated seats on.” which is very cool and it shows the exclusivity of owning a car that you can literally talk to.
So, which has the best interior? Whilst it is a very close call as both interiors are packed with the latest technology and they both are comfortable in their design, the Mercedes A-Class has a slight edge because their interior looks are more aesthetically pleasing.
Moreover, BMW stands for built and power, while Mercedes stands for class.
BMW 1 Series Vs Mercedes A-Class: Exterior Features
Now we have discussed the interior of the cars, let’s talk about the exterior. Both cars look very desirable on the outside and they are exactly what you’d expect them to be. The specifications of the BMW 1 Series that are available are: SE, Sport, and M Sport and the specifications of the Mercedes A-Class are: SE, Sport, and AMG Line. These levels of specifications that BMW and Mercedes offer are pretty much the same and it gives customers the opportunity to choose a specification that suits them.
However, Mercedes-Benz also offers extra packages which are: Executive, Premium, and Premium Plus. So if you are looking for an extra special package to add to your car, then you are best to look at the A-Class.
Upgrade your car effortlessly and for good money!
Discover how much your car is worth! Get the instant offer by entering just two details about your car. You will be instantly matched with the right car buyer ready to pay cash for your car.
BMW 1 Series Vs Mercedes A-Class: Which is Most Practical?
The BMW has the bigger boot, but at 380 liters it is only 10 liters bigger than the Mercedes’ boot. People don’t tend to purchase these sized cars because of their boot space, but it is always handy to have enough boot space to carry shopping and luggage for occasional travel and both cars are able to do so.
In terms of rear passenger space, both cars seem to have a similar amount of space. Although the A-Class is slightly lower to the ground so it is not ideal for people who struggle with mobility, as it makes it harder to get in and out of the vehicle.
It is also important to note that both cars have the average legroom and height for someone who has the height of 5”10 feet so you can fit a majority of adults in the back of either car.
In terms of practicality, the BMW 1 Series has the edge as the boot is bigger and the passenger area is slightly easier to get in and out of.
BMW 1 Series Vs Mercedes A-Class: Our Verdict
Both cars are very similar and it is a very close competition between the two. It is fair to say that the latest Mercedes A-Class is the most improved model as the interior is very innovative and it is a design that we do not see very often. However, the BMW 1 Series is the better car to buy overall as it is more practical and even though the interior may not be as exciting as the Mercedes A-Class, the BMW still has all the same latest technological features, so therefore the BMW 1 Series is our overall winner.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the main differences between the BMW 1 Series and Mercedes A-Class?
The BMW 1 Series and Mercedes A-Class are both premium compact cars, but they differ in driving dynamics, design, and technology. The BMW 1 Series emphasises sporty handling with its rear-wheel-drive platform, while the Mercedes A-Class focuses on luxury and advanced infotainment with the MBUX system. The BMW offers sharper steering, whereas the A-Class provides a more refined interior and smoother ride.
2. Which car is more fuel-efficient?
Fuel efficiency varies by engine and model. Generally, the Mercedes A-Class with its diesel or hybrid options (like the A250e plug-in hybrid) offers better fuel economy, especially for city driving. The BMW 1 Series, particularly in models like the 118i, is competitive but may lag slightly in hybrid efficiency. Check specific models for exact MPG or WLTP figures.
3. How do the interiors compare in terms of quality and technology?
The Mercedes A-Class typically has a more luxurious interior with higher-quality materials and a futuristic dual-screen MBUX infotainment system. The BMW 1 Series has a driver-focused cockpit with premium materials but a slightly less flashy design. Both offer advanced tech, but the A-Class’s voice-activated MBUX system is often considered more intuitive.
4. Which car is better for performance enthusiasts?
The BMW 1 Series, particularly models like the M135i xDrive, is better suited for performance enthusiasts due to its sportier handling, quicker steering, and optional all-wheel drive. The Mercedes A-Class, while capable (especially the AMG A35 or A45), prioritizes comfort over outright performance in most trims.
5. How do their prices compare?
Pricing depends on trim and options. The BMW 1 Series typically starts slightly lower, with a base price around £28,000 (e.g., 118i SE), while the Mercedes A-Class starts closer to £30,000 (e.g., A180). High-performance models like the BMW M135i or Mercedes AMG A35 can push prices toward £40,000 or more. Always compare specific trims and local deals.
Final Thoughts
Even though the BMW 1 Series is our overall winner, the Mercedes A-Class is still a very impressive car and it was a very close call. Are you looking to sell your Mercedes or sell your BMW car?
Exchange My Car can help you find expert Mercedes and BMW car buyers in the UK with a few clicks. Sell your car hassle-free and enjoy free collection and fast payment!
Sell your car effortlessly and for good money!
Discover how much your car is worth! Get the instant offer by entering just two details about your car. You will be instantly matched with the right car buyer ready to pay cash for your car.
